18 July 2006

Clemens' Notebook - History

English has only one basic word, "history." But German, for instance, has (1) Geschichte, or the academic discipline of history-writing; (2) Historie, or less formal narrative history; and (3) Storie, which may contain many mythical and folkloric elements, but nevertheless aims at a connected account of the past.
from What Did the Biblican Writers Know and When Did They Know it?, by William G. Dever

Thus English, with the largest vocabulary of any language, does not have enough words to cover the subject.

3 Comments:

At 19 July, 2006 15:27, Blogger Elliot said...

Bede's got some thoughts on that book here:
http://bedejournal.blogspot.com/2005/02/i-am-reading-rather-good-book-by.html

and here:
http://bedejournal.blogspot.com/2005/02/william-dever-wrote-his-book-what-did.html

and here:
http://bedejournal.blogspot.com/2005/03/here-are-some-further-thoughts-on.html

He also went on to compare and contrast some work by the biblical minimalists. Sounded pretty interesting.

 
At 26 July, 2006 00:13, Blogger Clemens said...

Thanks Elliot!
I'll check them out.

 
At 27 July, 2006 14:44, Blogger Clemens said...

OK - I've read them now. It has somewhat restored my faith in Bede. Nice summation of Dever's work, and at least one take down of the 'minimalists' of Biblical archaeology.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home